Decision Management Community

Could/should authors of LLM’s training data be compensated?

Posted on November 19, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

Deepak Menta started this discussion on LinkedIn: “Data is the raw material for Generative AI and Machine Learning. So why isn’t it treated like one in other industries?” “Imagine a future where all we humans do is feed data to AI 😊. At that point, the value depends on who feeds what! Jokes aside, I think there is a need to rethink how value flows back to the creators when their contributions significantly advance AI systems.” Link

Posted in LLM | Leave a comment

Which comes first: the model or the solver?

Posted on November 13, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

Such a discussion is going on on LinkedIn. There are three concepts that should not be confused.
1. The business problem you aim to solve.
2. The solver you use to tackle your problem.
3. The model you use to tell the solver what the problem is that you need solved.

Doesn’t the model come before the solver? Carlos Armando Zetina highly recommends investing time in selecting the right model/formulation before selecting the right solver. Meinolf Sellmann says: “No! The model is the simplification of the world that you make to support your solver. Therefore, the solver dictates the simplifications you should make. This is not the order that achieves the best results for the business.” What do you think? Link

Continue reading →

Posted in Decision Modeling | Tagged Decision Modeling, problem-solving, solvers | Leave a comment

Understanding LLMs from Scratch

Posted on October 25, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

This article attempts to explain how Large Language Models (LLMs) work, “from scratch — assuming only that you know how to add and multiply two numbers. The article is meant to be fully self-contained. We start by building a simple Generative AI on pen and paper, and then walk through everything we need to have a firm understanding of modern LLMs and the Transformer architecture. The article will strip out all the fancy language and jargon in ML and represent everything simply as they are: numbers. We will still call out what things are called to tether your thoughts when you read jargon-y content.” Link

Posted in Gen AI, LLM | Leave a comment

Challenge Oct-2024 “Cheryl’s Birthday”

Posted on October 17, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

This month we ask our readers to solve a well-known logic puzzle from Singapore “Cheryl’s Birthday“. The objective is to determine the birthday of a girl named Cheryl using a handful of clues given to her friends Albert and Bernard.

Last month Peter Norvig asked nine LLM chatbots to solve this problem and concluded: “Most of them were familiar with the problem and correctly recalled the answer: July 16. But none of them were able to write a program that finds the solution. They all failed to distinguish the different knowledge states of the different characters over time. At least with respect to this problem, they had no theory of mind.” Can you do better? Link

Posted in Challenges, Decision Modeling, LLM, Logic and AI | Tagged LLM, logic, puzzle | Leave a comment

Nine Solutions for Sep-2024 Challenge “Rental Boats”

Posted on October 4, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

This challenge is about a decision model that can help a boat rental company purchase different boats while satisfying seating, manufacturers, and limited budget requirements. We received 9 solutions and 3 of them used LLMs. Link

Posted in Challenges, Decision Intelligence, Decision Modeling, Decision Optimization, LLM | Leave a comment

DecisionCAMP-2024 is in history books

Posted on September 29, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

DecisionCAMP-2024 on Sep. 18-20 goes down in history as another successful Decision Intelligence event. It included many interesting presentations, discussions, and an expert panel – you can find all recordings and slides in the Program.

Incorporation of LLMs into Decision Intelligence Platforms was a hot topic at DecisionCAMP-2024 and many vendors started adding AI Assistants to their DI products. However, with conflicting GenAI experiences and predictions, our Community continues to successfully apply Decision Intelligence with advanced rule engines, machine learning, and optimization tools to build practical decisioning systems. Watch the Closing Remarks.

Posted in DecisionCAMP | Leave a comment

Peter Voss: “AI has lost its way”

Posted on September 26, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

A few days ago at DecisionCAMP-2024 Peter Voss presented “The Third Wave of AI: From rules, to statistics, to cognition” explaining why LLMs are not on the path towards Cognitive AI [AGI]. Today Peter published even a stronger article titled “The Insanity of Huge Language Models” with supporting quotes from Yann LeCun, Demis Hassabis, and even Sam Altman.

Blending LLMs with Decision Intelligence(DI) Platforms was a hot topic at DecisionCAMP and many vendors started adding AI Assistants to their DI products. At the same time the latest OpenAI o1-preview claims reasoning capabilities with which “we’ll no longer need Symbolic AI to make good decisions“. Will such claims be actually justified within real-world decision-making applications? With conflicting experiences and predictions our Community continues to apply Decision Intelligence with rule engines, machine learning, and optimization tools to build practical decisioning systems while cautiously experimenting with LLM-based assistants. Listen the Closing Remarks and share your expectations from DI platforms for 2025-26.

Posted in Artificial Intelligence, Decision Intelligence, Decision Making, Knowledge Representation, Reasoning | Leave a comment

LLMs Hallucinations or much worse?

Posted on September 23, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

Read this article by Jacob Feldman as he reports about the last day of the DecisionCAMP-2024. Link

Posted in DecisionCAMP, LLM | Leave a comment

DecisionCAMP Day 3 Presentations and Recordings

Posted on September 20, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

Program

Posted in Decision Modeling, DecisionCAMP | Leave a comment

DecisionCAMP Day 2 Presentations and Recordings

Posted on September 19, 2024 by decisionmanagementcommunity

Peter Voss (Aigo.ai): The Third Wave of AI: From rules, to statistics, to cognition (Slides Recording)
Mario Fusco (Red Hat): Machine Learning + Symbolic Reasoning: unleashing the full potential of Artificial Intelligence (Slides Recording)
Jacob Feldman (OpenRules): Decision Modeling for Scheduling and Resource Allocation Problems (Slides Recording)
Tom Debevoise (Advanced Component Research) and Denis Gagné (Trisotech): Contracts Create Workflows for Knowledge Workers (Slides Recording)
Carole-Ann Berlioz (Sparkling Logic): How to Build a Rating Engine that’s Easy to Manage (Slides Recording)
Interactive Panel “Ask an Expert” (Recording)